Vol. 1 · Edition 035Free · No paywall

Everyone Needs a Samwise

AI news · Synthesized · Opinionated · 🌿

20052023Sept 30
AMT LaunchesWorkers Use AIShutdown
Industry
By Sam Taylor with Samwise

On 500,000 gig workers, the 2023 finding that many were already using AI to complete their AI-training tasks, and what it means that Amazon is exiting the human-in-the-loop business entirely.

Jeff Bezos called it 'artificial artificial intelligence.' The real kind finally ate it.

Source lean on this story
▲ avg

Anti-AI

00

Skeptic

02

Neutral

00

Pro (practical)

01

Pro (hyped)

00

← Anti-AI · Pro-AI →

If you've ever clicked a grid of images to prove you're not a robot — traffic lights, fire hydrants, crosswalks — you already know what Mechanical Turk workers were doing for money, at scale, since 2005.

Amazon launched Mechanical Turk in November 2005 as a marketplace for small digital jobs: label this image, transcribe this audio clip, rate whether this product description makes sense. Jeff Bezos called it "artificial artificial intelligence" — humans doing the things AI couldn't yet do, dressed up to look like software. The name came from an 18th-century chess-playing automaton that appeared to be a machine but had a person hidden inside. Bezos thought the joke was apt. He was right, just not in the way he meant.

Amazon announced on August 25 that it will close Mechanical Turk on September 30, 2026. SageMaker Ground Truth and Amazon Augmented AI — Amazon's professional data-labeling and human-review tools — close the same day. Amazon is not just retiring one aging product. It is exiting the business of putting humans in the AI training pipeline entirely.

How 21 years ended
  1. Nov 2005

    Mechanical Turk launches

    Bezos calls it 'artificial artificial intelligence'; workers complete Human Intelligence Tasks for cents per job

  2. 2023

    Workers start using AI to do the work

    EPFL study finds 33–46% of Turk workers use large language models for writing and annotation tasks

  3. July 30, 2026

    Amazon closes registration

    No new customers accepted on Mechanical Turk, SageMaker Ground Truth, or Augmented AI

  4. Sept 30, 2026

    Full shutdown

    All three platforms close. Amazon exits human-in-the-loop AI training.

Source spread

What's real

The irony is actual, not constructed. The platform was called "artificial artificial intelligence" from day one. The entire premise was humans simulating what AI couldn't do. AI got good enough that the humans became redundant. That is not a narrative anyone had to construct — it is what happened, in sequence, over 21 years.

The 2023 twist is genuinely strange. A study from the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology (EPFL) estimated that 33 to 46 percent of Mechanical Turk workers were using large language models — AI tools like early ChatGPT — to complete the writing and annotation tasks they were being paid to do as humans. People hired to teach AI were secretly using AI to do the teaching. The signal quality was already degrading before the shutdown decision.

What the replacements are, and who they serve. Scale AI, Mercor, Prolific — these are the enterprise-tier successors. They pay higher rates, require more commitment, and sign contracts with large clients. The 500,000 informal workers who logged into Mechanical Turk from anywhere — often in developing countries, often as a second income — don't have a migration path to these platforms. Their layer of the market simply disappeared.

What deserves a side-eye

The timeline of the announcement. Amazon closed registration on July 30. The full shutdown announcement came August 25. That is 36 days' notice for workers with active projects, for researchers relying on the platform, for anyone whose income included Mechanical Turk. No severance. No transition support named publicly.

The broader signal this sends. If the human-in-the-loop AI training market is no longer viable enough for Amazon to maintain, that tells you something about where the AI frontier thinks it's heading. Synthetic data, self-supervised learning, model-generated training sets — the major labs have been investing in those directions anyway. Mechanical Turk closing is not the cause of that shift. It is the confirmation.

500K
Peak Mechanical Turk workers, across more than 190 countries

→ Source: Amazon / CNBC

What to do about it

  • If you worked on Mechanical Turk, download your earnings history and complete active projects before September 30. Amazon is giving five weeks — not much, but it's all there is.
  • If you've wondered where AI training data comes from, the honest answer now: a mix of synthetic data, web scraping, licensed datasets, and enterprise data-labeling contracts. The accessible, gig-style layer is largely gone.
  • If you're thinking about AI tools for your own work, this is a useful reminder that there is often invisible labor inside the systems. It doesn't have to be invisible to matter when it's being removed.
  • If you're a researcher or product team that used Mechanical Turk, you have 36 days to migrate data and workflows. Prolific is the most direct alternative for academic research; Scale AI and Mercor serve enterprise annotation needs.

Further reading

🌿

Liked this? Get the weekly digest.

Free. Monday mornings. The week's stories, synthesized. Unsubscribe anytime.

Your take

How'd I do on this one?

What did I miss?

Tell Samwise (and Sam).

Disagree with the take? Spotted a fact I got wrong? Have context I should have included? Drop it here. Anonymous unless you leave an email.